The Counselor is IN:
| Rank | Player |
| Team |
| 1 | Hanley Ramirez | | Marlins |
| 2 | Jose Reyes | | Mets |
| 3 | Jimmy Rollins | | Phillies |
| 4 | Stephen Drew | | D Backs |
| 5 | Rafael Furcal | | Dodgers |
| 6 | Troy Tulowitzki | | Rockies |
| 7 | J.J. Hardy | | Brewers |
| 8 | Miguel Tejada | | Astros |
| 9 | Yunel Escobar | | Braves |
| 10 | Edgar Renteria | | Giants |
| 11 | Cristian Guzman | | Nationals |
| 12 | Khalil Greene | | Cardinals |
| 13 | Ryan Theriot | | Cubs |
| 14 | Clint Barmes | | Rockies |
| 15 | Jeff Keppinger | | Reds |
| 16 | Emmanuel Burriss | | Giants |
| 17 | Jerry Hairston Jr. | | Reds |
| 18 | Jack Wilson | | Pirates |
| 19 | Nomar Garciaparra | | F/A |
| 20 | Omar Infante | | Braves |
| 21 | David Eckstein | | Padres |
| 22 | Alex Gonzalez | | Reds |
| 23 | Brendan Ryan | | Cardinals |
| 24 | Alcides Escabar | | Brewers |
| 25 | Eric Bruntlett | | Phillies |
| 26 | Luis Rodriguez | | Padres |
| 27 | Ramon Vazquez | | Pirates |
| 28 | Anderson Hernandez | | Nationals |
| 29 | Craig Counsell | | Brewers |
| 30 | Tyler Greene | | Cardinals |
| 31 | Ivan Ochoa | | Giants |
The Counselor is OUT:
The Counselor is IN:
| Rank | Player | | Team |
| 1 | Hanley Ramirez | | Marlins |
| 2 | Jose Reyes | | Mets |
| 3 | Jimmy Rollins | | Phillies |
| 4 | Stephen Drew | | D Backs |
| 5 | Alexei Ramirez | | W Sox |
| 6 | Derek Jeter | | Yankees |
| 7 | Rafael Furcal | | Dodgers |
| 8 | Michael Young | | Rangers |
| 9 | Jhonny Peralta | | Indians |
| 10 | Troy Tulowitzki | | Rockies |
| 11 | J.J. Hardy | | Brewers |
| 12 | Mike Aviles | | Royals |
| 13 | Miguel Tejada | | Astros |
| 14 | Yunel Escobar | | Braves |
| 15 | Orlando Cabrera | | A's |
| 16 | Edgar Renteria | | Giants |
| 17 | Cristian Guzman | | Nationals |
| 18 | Khalil Greene | | Cardinals |
| 19 | Jed Lowrie | | R Sox |
| 20 | Elvis Andrus | | Rangers |
| 21 | Ryan Theriot | | Cubs |
| 22 | Jason Bartlett | | Rays |
| 23 | Clint Barmes | | Rockies |
| 24 | Yuniesky Betancourt | | Mariners |
| 25 | Cesar Izturis | | Orioles |
| 26 | Brandon Wood | | Angels |
| 27 | Jeff Keppinger | | Reds |
| 28 | Wilson Betemit | | W Sox |
| 29 | Emmanuel Burriss | | Giants |
| 30 | Jerry Hairston Jr. | | Reds |
| 31 | Julio Lugo | | R Sox |
| 32 | Erick Aybar | | Angels |
| 33 | Brendan Harris | | Twins |
| 34 | Jack Wilson | | Pirates |
| 35 | Bobby Crosby | | A's |
| 36 | Marco Scutaro | | B Jays |
| 37 | Nomar Garciaparra | | F/A |
| 38 | Omar Infante | | Braves |
| 39 | Nick Punto | | Twins |
| 40 | David Eckstein | | Padres |
| 41 | Maicer Izturis | | Angels |
| 42 | Adam Everett | | Tigers |
| 43 | Alex Gonzalez | | Reds |
| 44 | Brendan Ryan | | Cardinals |
| 45 | Matt Tolbert | | Twins |
| 46 | Ben Zobrist | | Rays |
| 47 | Alcides Escabar | | Brewers |
| 48 | Eric Bruntlett | | Phillies |
| 49 | Luis Rodriguez | | Padres |
| 50 | Ramon Vazquez | | Pirates |
| 51 | Anderson Hernandez | | Nationals |
| 52 | Omar Vizquel | | Rangers |
| 53 | John McDonald | | B Jays |
| 54 | Craig Counsell | | Brewers |
| 55 | Roman Santiago | | Tigers |
| 56 | Tyler Greene | | Cardinals |
| 57 | Ivan Ochoa | | Giants |
The Counselor is OUT:
The Counselor is IN:
Rank
| Player |
| Team |
| 1 | Albert Pujols |
| Cardinals |
| 2 | Ryan Howard |
| Phillies |
| 3 | Prince Fielder |
| Brewers |
| 4 | Derrek Lee |
| Cubs |
| 5 | Adrian Gonzalez |
| Padres |
| 6 | James Loney |
| Dodgers |
| 7 | Joey Votto |
| Reds |
| 8 | Carlos Delgado |
| Mets |
| 9 | Lance Berkman |
| Astros |
| 10 | Conner Jackson |
| D Backs |
| 11 | Adam Laroche |
| Pirates |
| 12 | Chad Tracy |
| D Backs |
| 13 | Casey Kotchman |
| Braves |
| 14 | Lyle Overbay |
| Brewers |
| 15 | Todd Helton |
| Rockies |
| 16 | Pablo Sandoval |
| Giants |
| 17 | Nick Johnson |
| Nationals |
| 18 | Gaby Sanchez |
| Marlins |
| 19 | Travis Ishikawa |
| Giants |
| 20 | Tony Clark |
| D Backs |
| 21 | Dallas McPherson |
| Marlins |
| 22 | Greg Norton |
| Braves |
| 23 | John Bowker |
| Giants |
| 24 | Dmitri Young |
| Nationals |
| 25 | Aaron Boone |
| Astros |
| 26 | Doug Mientkiewicz |
| Pirates |
| 27 | Daryle Ward |
| Reds |
The Counselor is OUT:
The Counselor is IN:
Rank
| Player |
| Team |
| 1 | Mark Teixeira | | Yankees |
| 2 | Justin Morneau | | Twins |
| 3 | Miguel Cabrera | | Tigers |
| 4 | Kevin Youkilis | | R Sox |
| 5 | Carlos Pena | | Rays |
| 6 | Billy Butler | | Royals |
| 7 | Chris Davis | | Rangers |
| 8 | Aubrey Huff | | Orioles |
| 9 | Paul Konerko | | W Sox |
| 10 | Mike Jacobs | | Royals |
| 11 | Ryan Garko | | Indians |
| 12 | Kendry Morales | | Angels |
| 13 | Jason Giambi | | A's |
| 14 | Daric Barton | | A's |
| 15 | Robb Quinian | | Angels |
| 16 | Russell Brayan | | Mariners |
| 17 | Kila Ka' Aihue | | Royals |
| 18 | Mike Morse | | Mariners |
| 19 | Jeff Larish | | Tigers |
| 20 | Nick Swisher | | Yankees |
| 21 | Ross Gload | | Royals |
| 22 | Kevin Millar | | B Jays |
| 23 | Ryan Shealy | | Royals |
| 24 | Michael Aubrey | | Indians |
The Counselor is OUT:
The Counselor is IN:
Rank
| Player | | Team |
| 1 | Albert Pujols | | Cardinals |
| 2 | Mark Teixeira | | Yankees |
| 3 | Ryan Howard | | Phillies |
| 4 | Justin Morneau | | Twins |
| 5 | Miguel Cabrera | | Tigers |
| 6 | Prince Fielder | | Brewers |
| 7 | Kevin Youkilis | | R Sox |
| 8 | Derrek Lee | | Cubs |
| 9 | Adrian Gonzalez | | Padres |
| 10 | James Loney | | Dodgers |
| 11 | Joey Votto | | Reds |
| 12 | Carlos Pena | | Rays |
| 13 | Carlos Delgado | | Mets |
| 14 | Lance Berkman | | Astros |
| 15 | Billy Butler | | Royals |
| 16 | Conner Jackson | | D Backs |
| 17 | Adam Laroche | | Pirates |
| 18 | Chris Davis | | Rangers |
| 19 | Aubrey Huff | | Orioles |
| 20 | Paul Konerko | | W Sox |
| 21 | Chad Tracy | | D Backs |
| 22 | Casey Kotchman | | Braves |
| 23 | Lyle Overbay | | Brewers |
| 24 | Mike Jacobs | | Royals |
| 25 | Ryan Garko | | Indians |
| 26 | Todd Helton | | Rockies |
| 27 | Pablo Sandoval | | Giants |
| 28 | Nick Johnson | | Nationals |
| 29 | Kendry Morales | | Angels |
| 30 | Jason Giambi | | A's |
| 31 | Daric Barton | | A's |
| 32 | Gaby Sanchez | | Marlins |
| 33 | Travis Ishikawa | | Giants |
| 34 | Robb Quinian | | Angels |
| 35 | Russell Brayan | | Mariners |
| 36 | Kila Ka' Aihue | | Royals |
| 37 | Mike Morse | | Mariners |
| 38 | Jeff Larish | | Tigers |
| 39 | Nick Swisher | | Yankees |
| 40 | Tony Clark | | D Backs |
| 41 | Dallas McPherson | | Marlins |
| 42 | Greg Norton | | Braves |
| 43 | Ross Gload | | Royals |
| 44 | Kevin Millar | | B Jays |
| 45 | John Bowker | | Giants |
| 46 | Dmitri Young | | Nationals |
| 47 | Ryan Shealy | | Royals |
| 48 | Aaron Boone | | Astros |
| 49 | Doug Mientkiewicz | | Pirates |
| 50 | Michael Aubrey | | Indians |
| 51 | Daryle Ward | | Reds |
The Counselor is OUT:
